Sunday, 14 September 2014

Christianity v.s The Olympic Religion

I researched the similarities between Christianity and the Olympian religion because both were popular in their time. What I found was most surprising. Here is my paragraph I used in my essay:

Although Christianity is viewed as being the polar opposite to the Olympian religion, there are enough similarities between the two faiths that suggest Christianity was influenced by the Greek religion. Christianity is most commonly known to have been founded from Judaism, and many of the stories before Jesus Christ have been derived from that religion. However the parallels between the stories from the bible and tales from Greek myths are unprecedented, particularly with themes such as the treachery of women, the first people, and the great flood. In both the bible and the Olympian religion, the first women were the cause of all suffering on earth because of their weakness: curiosity and inability to follow instructions set by the gods. In the bible stories of Christianity, it is an accepted story that it was Eve, the first woman created by God, who took the forbidden fruit form the tree and ate it. She also, “gave some to her husband, and he also ate it”[1], and therefore they gained wisdom at the expense of, “the Lord God sent them out of the Garden of Eden and made them cultivate the soil”[2], and they could not return to paradise or have internal life.  Similarly, the first woman in the Olympian religion, named Pandora, was created by Zeus[3] to punish man. She, “possessed a sealed urn”[4], which she was instructed not to open, but eventually her curiosity drove her to open it. As a result, “she scattered its contents throughout the world: toil, disease, an earthly death”[5], hence she brought agony and hardship as well as a shortened the lifespan of man. Another theme that is common with both religions is that the first people lived in a perfect world of peace and prosperity with no pain or sadness before wickedness was commenced from the first woman. In the Olympian religion, the first people were the golden race of mortals who, “lived free from all cares and worries, eternally young”[6], and they lived in peace and prosperity until the wars between gods destroyed them. Correspondingly, Adam and Eve lived in the Garden of Eden, which is considered a paradise, before they ate the forbidden fruit and were banished from the garden. The Great Flood is the most commonly known to be the most similar between the Olympian religion and Christianity, as well as having the most similarities. Both floods were caused by the superior gods[7] to wipe out humanity because sin has taken over where worship once was. Only a few humans chosen by the gods were allowed to survive and, “repopulate the world, passing on their knowledge, skills and high moral standard”[8], to avoid such a catastrophe again. In the case of the Olympian religion, “Zeus disguised himself as a traveller”[9], and went to a common oikos[10] to assess the development of humanity. What he found were the people of the oikos serving a meal of human flesh, which enraged Zeus and he became, “determined to destroy the human race. He decided to do so by the means of a deluge that would inundate the earth, drowning all the people”[11], and nearly all the people on earth died, either from starvation or drowning. Only two humans remained, Deucalion, son of Prometheus and king of Pthia and his wife Pyrrha. They had been pre-warned by Prometheus, whose duty as a god was to protect the human race, and hence they were able to build a boat that was plentiful with supplies before the storm hit. Likewise in Christianity, “The Lord saw how wicked everyone on earth was and how evil their thoughts were all the time, he was sorry that he had ever made them and put them on the earth”[12], and summoned a great flood to destroy all of humanity. Before doing so, the Lord approached Noah, knowing that he was a loyal disciple and told him to, “build a boat for yourself out of good timber”[13], so that he, his family and two of all animals on earth can survive on the boat as the floods destroy the evil that humanity had created. Despite the appearance of being completely different religions and faiths, the stories that are presented in the Bible of Christianity have some parallels with the Olympian religion, such as the themes of the treachery of women, the first people who lived in paradise, and the great flood.



[1]Good News Bible. The Bible Society in Australia, Canberra. 1983. P. 4.
[2] ibid. P. 5.
[3] The god of the sky and the King of the Greek gods.
[4] Ruck, C. and Staples, D., The World of Classical Myth: Goods and Goddesses, Heroines and Heroes. Carolina Academic Press, North Carolina, 1994. P. 41.
[5] ibid.
[6] Allan, T. and Maitland, S., Titans and Olympians: Greek and Roman Myth. Duncan Baird Publishers, London. 1997. P. 36.
[7] It was the Lord for Christianity and Zeus for the Olympian religion that created the Great Flood.
[8] ibid. P. 38.
[9] Ruck, C. and Staples, D., The World of Classical Myth: Goods and Goddesses, Heroines and Heroes. Carolina Academic Press, North Carolina, 1994. P. 42.
[10] Greek word for ‘household’
[11] Allan, T. and Maitland, S., Titans and Olympians: Greek and Roman Myth. Duncan Baird Publishers, London. 1997. P. 38.
[12] Good News Bible. The Bible Society in Australia, Canberra. 1983. P. 6.
[13] ibid. P. 7.

Monday, 8 September 2014

Plan for My Essay

I have slightly changed my question to:

To what extent did the Olympian religion influence other religions?

Just because the question I had before was a little bit broad, I wanted to narrow it down just so it appears that I am answering the question in my essay. Here are the three points that I will be talking about in my essay:

Roman Mythology v.s Greek Mythology
It is common knowledge that Greek mythology had a heavy influence over Roman Mythology, but of course it is the question of how much influence. For example, I know that the Romans changes the names of the immortals when they introduced the Greek mythology, but I wondered why and where did the names come from. 

Christianity v.s. Greek Mythology
I chose Christianity as another paragraph because I knew that Christianity was created during the time where Greek mythology was popular and I wondered is their was any parallels between the two different religions.

Hellenistic Religion v.s. Greek Mythology
I only found out about this religion when I was researching for any other religions that were influenced by the Greeks. Its not so much of a religion. but it is a belief system used by the people that was mostly influenced by the Greeks, but it also has other religions incorporated with it as well, such as the Romans and Egyptology. I don't know a lot on this religion like the others, but I plan to find out. 

Roman Mythology v.s. Greek Mythology

Here is my paragraph on the influence that Greek mythology had on Roman Mythology. Tell me what you think:

The Roman religion is the most well-known example of a religion adopting the Olympian beliefs and stories and merging them with their own mythology. During the developing stages of the Roman Empire, particularly in the early stages at approximately 500 B.C., “the eastern provinces were steeped in the culture of Greece”[1], due to contact with nearby Greek colonies. Because of this, many Romans, “adopted many of its religious and philosophical beliefs together with its elaborate mythology”[2], and merged it with their own beliefs as they were nowhere near as elaborate and colourful. Unlike the Greeks, the Romans were not creators of myth. Their belief was that objects and events had a supernatural force and were labelled as gods, but they were not of human form and the Romans did not worship them in the earlier times. When the Roman Empire had expanded to cover the Greek nation by 146 B.C., the Greek gods could have diminished into insignificance, however the, “Roman religion was very open ended”[3], and this left, “the Greek family of gods more or less unchanged, merging their personalities with characteristics of their own native powers and spirits”[4], and thereby preserving the ancient Greek culture. The Olympian immortals attained Roman counterparts[5], and in the development of these characteristics, many of the native Roman gods emerged with their status greatly increased. For example, in Roman mythology, Venus[6] was a minor figure, but the connection to Aphrodite turned her into a popular and sacred goddess. In reverse, Ares’[7] importance was increased by his association to Mars, as the Romans regarded him over many of the other deities. With the rapid increase of popularity with the gods and the wealth of material suddenly opened up to them, Roman poets, “began retelling the Greek tales in Latin, substituting the Roman names for the gods”[8], and this also assisted in the preservation of the Olympian religion: despite the poets frequently elaborated the stories, they rarely invented new material. Regardless of all this borrowing from the ancient Olympian religion, “the Roman religion remained a separate entity, with its own distinct atmosphere and identity”[9], because most of the foundation for their gods was from the original Roman beliefs. For instance, “while Greek religion was a civic faith, Roman worship had domestic roots in the farms and estates of the city’s agricultural hinterland”[10], because the early Romans were farmers and relied upon the land for their survival and prosperity. As the Roman Empire grew, the Olympian religion was adopted into Roman society and became a large part of the Roman lifestyle, however the Romans continued to use their own names for the gods and the religion remained a separate entity.



[1] Usher, K., Heroes, Gods and Goddesses from Roman Mythology. Hodder & Stoughton Pty, New South Wales. 1983. P. 12.
[2]ibid.
[3]ibid. P. 13.
[4]ibid.
[5] For example: Zeus became Jupiter; Hera, Juno; Hermes, Mercury; Persidon, Neptune; Athena, Minerva. (Allan, T. and Maitland, S., Titans and Olympians: Greek and Roman Myth. Duncan Baird Publishers, London. 1997. P. 138.)  
[6] The Roman Goddess of  love, beauty, fertility and marriage.
[7] The Greek God of  war.
[8] ibid. P. 15.
[9] ibid. P. 16.
[10] ibid. P. 17. 

Sunday, 22 June 2014

Final Essay Question!

After some discussion with my Classical teacher, I have decided to base my Special Study on this question:

To what extent did the Olympian religion reflect the values and world view of the mortals that created it?


As a "to what extent" question, I need to look at both sides of the argument. I would need to have extensive knowledge on the Olympian religion and how that links to values. Mortals may not just extend to the Greeks, it could also be other mortals, which is where the link from the Greek religion with other religions come in. Would view may be how the Greeks view the world or something along those lines. 

If their is anything else I can include, don't hesitate to comment!

Saturday, 17 May 2014

Special Study Questions!

Here are some questions that I may use for my special study. Some of them I made myself, others I found off of old exam papers.Most, if not all, are related to Greek mythology, because that is the area I intend to study. Feedback would be nice!

'Desire and fear motivated the Greeks to communicate with their gods in
a variety of ways.' To what extent do you agree with this statement? 2010 
exam question

To what extent did the Greek mythology inspire other religions? My own 
question

'Whereas the Olympian religion was based on fear, mystery religions were
based on hope.' To what extent do you agree with this statement? 2009 
exam question

'In Greek religion, females held equal status with males.' To what extent
do you agree with this statement? 2009 exam question

'Although Greek sacred stories portrayed scandalous behaviour, they also
provided moral lessons for the Greeks to observe.' Discuss this
statement. 2007 exam question

Unlike many other religions, the Greek Olympian immortals have many
human traits. Why would this be the case? My own question

'The Greek Olympian religion was primarily a meditated religious
experience.' To what extent do you agree with this statement? 2007 exam 
question

Thursday, 15 May 2014

Special Studies Log

This log is a bit like a mini blog that I will update every time I work on my special study. The purpose is to prove that I have done the work and it informed my Classics teacher where I am up to in my study.

01.05.2014
I have started my log and my bibliography on my blog. Also had a chat to my teacher about what I need to do.

05.05.2014
Fixed some problems with my blog, published my bibliography, and was given some new reading material. The show that I really liked was taken off of youtube due to copyright violations, so I am trying to track it down again. I have some idea about what my study question will be.

06.05.2014
I went through the exam papers that was used when Classical Studies did have an exam (I am so happy that I missed out!) and I found some good questions that at I could use. I wrote them on my iPad, because my laptop died, so the next step it to create a new page with the questions.

08.05.2014
Did some more work on my blog, such as creating a page for all my researched questions and updating my log. Doing some more reading on general websites, but I am not sure whether to include them in my blog.

16.05.2014
I'm trying to update my blog and get more familiar with using this website. We have a check point coming up, so I am trying to get things organised.

18.05.2014
Finally got the study questions onto my blog. I am looking for some more sites that may come in handy.

23.06.2014
Its been a while since I have updated this blog, I promise I have been doing some special study here and there! I have made a page about my final essay question and the aspects that I should look at. I have updated my bibliography and now that I know specifically what I should research, I am looking for more resources.

19.08.2014 ~ 22.08.2014
Did some work on my essay and found some good resources. I completed the Roman v.s. Greek section of my essay and got it drafted by Mr Stewart.

09.09.2014
Updated Log and Bibliography. Created a new pages named Roman Mythology v.s. Greek Mythology and my plan for  my essay.

11.09.09.2014
Updated Log. Created a new page for Christianity v.s Olympian page.

14.09.2014
Created Hellenistic Religion page.


15.09.2014
Updated log and published Christianity v.s Olympian page. Updated bibliography.

16.09.2014.
Updated log and published Hellenistic page.

Monday, 5 May 2014

Bibliography

Here I shall put some useful sources that may help with my research. I will update it as I go further into the research.

Allan, T. and Maitland, S., Titans and Olympians: Greek and Roman Myth. Duncan Baird Publishers, London. 1997.
Good News Bible. The Bible Society in Australia, Canberra. 1983.
History2009 Greek MythologyA+E NetworksUnited Kingdom, accessed May 2014, <http://www.history.com/topics/ancient-history/greek-mythology>.
Homer, translated by Chapman G., The Illiad. Wordsworth Classics, Hertfordshire. 2003.
Homer, translated by Reiv E.V., The Odyssey. Penguin, London. 1967.
Ruck, C. and Staples, D., The World of Classical Myth: Goods and Goddesses, Heroines and Heroes. Carolina Academic Press, North Carolina, 1994.
Usher, K., Heroes, Gods and Goddesses from Roman Mythology. Hodder & Stoughton Pty, New South Wales. 1983.

Monday, 28 April 2014

April School Holiday Research!

It is the day before school resumes and I realised that I may need to record what I have been researching during the holidays for my special study.

I have done a little research, and I have decided that I would like to study mythology, because I find this the most interesting about the classical world and it is the reason why I enjoy Classical Studies so much. What first came to mind was the stories of the ancient Greeks, as they have a wide range of stories and I am familiar with a few of them. Due to my interest with these stories, I researched a few on a number of occasions, such as the creation of my research project last year where I almost picked it as a topic, or reading a book series called Percy Jackson which is based around Greek mythology. Certainly, I became more knowledgeable during the study of The Odyssey by Homer and translated by E.V. Rieu in the first term.

During my research, I have found a few sources that I found particularly interesting and could be used for later reference:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pEVR-chjNxU
This video I found on youtube was a good introduction to the topic. It gives a summary of the stories and where they come from and their possible influence over other religions. Of course, this video is a rather old account, so I took what it stated with a pinch of salt, meaning I would need another source of information to back up their findings. What I did find interesting in this video is that it suggested that the Greeks may have influenced the stories in other religions, such as the Romans and even Christianity. I thought that this may be a good topic for my special study. A particular quote that I took to heart was, "Most of what we know about the Greek gods came from literary texts from that time period such as Homer's writings", therefore to get a primary source of information would be to look at The Illiad, which I am pleased to say that I have my own copy, and The Odyssey, which I also have in my possession from Term 1, but I may have to re-borrow it from the library for this new term.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQN1vGmHxs4
This video is the first episode of a series called Clash of the Gods, and it focuses on Zeus. The other episodes are about other famous Greek figures, such as Medusa and Hades. I even found one on Odysseus, who was the main character of The Odyssey. These videos are newer than the first one I saw, and It focuses on one topic, therefore I can use it to look at particular topic if I need too, which could become handy. I really like this show, because it provides some fact and evidence to the stories, such as large volcanic eruption that caused the earth to shake violently was caused by a large battle between the Titans and the Olympians. Therefore, this may be another direction that I could take my special study: providing some fact to the fiction.

I would like some more guidance before I get too engrossed and realise that I am going off track. For the mean time, I'm happy with just watching these videos. Youtube is my saviour!